| Departed | Name | Notes |
| J. Massello | PGK | |
| P. Stegle | ||
| F. Marquis | ||
| C. Poe | Nicknamed 'Kim' | |
| William Smith | ||
| Wayne Smith | ||
| H. Chandler | ||
| D. Jones | ||
| J. Woody, Jr. | ||
| J. Kucinski | ||
| V. Hicks, Jr. | PGK | |
| P. Meek, III | PGK, nicknamed 'Teddy' | |
| P. Marquis | ||
| P. McGrath | PGK | |
| A. Sosnowski | ||
| J. Pometto | ||
| J. Kane | ||
| D. Holman | ||
| C. Bullock | ||
| J.. Moore | ||
| R. Brewster | ||
| R. Wilkinson, Jr. | ||
| Jun, 2013 | R. Oberbrockling | |
| Rev. W. McGuire, OMI | ||
| F. Carley | Charter GK | |
| F. Brolly | ||
| A.. DelVecchio | ||
| T. Flanagan | ||
| Mar, 2024 | A. Verostko, Sr. | |
| Oct, 2024 | J. O'Connell | |
| Dec, 2024 | E. McCarron | |
| Jan, 2026 | L. Ambrogi | Founding member |